All mysteries
Mystery #3Tier 3chemistry / solids

Why is a diamond so hard but pencil 'lead' so soft, when both are pure carbon?

Diamond is the hardest natural material on Earth: it can scratch glass and steel. The 'lead' in your pencil is so soft it crumbles onto paper just by dragging it along. Yet here's the twist: both are made of nothing but carbon atoms, the exact same ingredient. So how can the same stuff be the hardest thing going AND one of the softest?

A raw, uncut diamond crystal, pure carbon locked into a rigid, glassy crystal shape.
Photo: W.carter, Wikimedia Commons · CC BY-SA 4.0 · via Wikimedia Commons

Your guess

What's your hunch about how the same carbon can be super-hard as diamond yet soft as pencil lead?

There's no single magic word to type, have a go in your own words, then reveal the answer to see how close you got.

Make a guess to unlock the hints and the answer.